Why Real Madrid Refuse to Pay €50m Release Clause for Alvaro Carreras

As Real Madrid look to build a dominant squad under Xabi Alonso’s stewardship, their hunt for a long-term left-back has brought them to Benfica’s Alvaro Carreras. Yet, despite keen interest, the Spanish giants have stopped short of activating the €50 million (£42m/$57m) release clause inserted in Carreras’ current contract. Instead, the La Liga outfit are pursuing a different route — a calculated, familiar method of negotiations that aligns with both their sporting strategy and broader financial outlook.

Madrid’s Calculated Approach: Why Pay in Full?

Real Madrid’s reluctance to meet Carreras’ buyout clause stems primarily from their intent to avoid an immediate, single payment that would stress their financial planning. Activating release clauses in Spain necessitates paying the entire fee upfront, an outlay that not only restricts liquidity but may also invite punitive tax rates.

Instead, Madrid are seeking to follow a path similar to their deals for Dean Huijsen and Franco Mastantuono — staggered payments over a predefined period. By proposing €40m (£34m/$46m), with Benfica countering at €48m (£40m/$55m), Florentino Perez and his directors hope to strike a balance between fiscal responsibility and squad reinforcement.

Additionally, negotiations are further complicated by a 20% resale clause owed to Manchester United, Carreras’ former employers. Any outright purchase would therefore see a significant chunk immediately diverted elsewhere, which diminishes Madrid’s appetite for an instant agreement.

Benfica Stand Firm: Rui Costa’s Unwavering Stance

From Benfica’s side, president Rui Costa has made their position unambiguously clear. Speaking from Florida, where both clubs are competing in the Club World Cup, Costa said:

“We haven’t reached an agreement with Madrid. There were proposals that didn’t convince us. Not for Alvaro or any other player.”

The message: Benfica won’t fold under pressure. They hold a key asset, know Madrid’s need is genuine, and are leveraging that position to extract maximum value — not just in terms of total fee but also in how and when that money will arrive in Lisbon.

For Carreras himself, the situation remains one of limbo. He is admired in Madrid, identified as a modern full-back with athleticism and attacking verve, but for now, he stays a Benfica player, caught between two boardrooms negotiating chess moves across continents.

Club World Cup Context: The Financial Imperative

Madrid’s transfer strategy cannot be viewed in isolation from their concurrent objectives. The Club World Cup in Florida presents a dual opportunity — restore sporting dominance after a dismal, trophyless season, and secure a massive financial windfall.

While last season ended with little silverware, this summer could mark a dramatic reset. Should Alonso’s men go all the way in the tournament, Real Madrid could walk away with up to $130 million (£97m), dwarfing previous projections of around €20 million. Even a clean sweep of their group games would add another $6 million (£4.4m).

For a board obsessed with long-term sustainability and immediate sporting success, such windfalls offset their reluctance to commit to lump-sum transfer deals.

Sporting Challenges: Alonso’s Tactical Balancing Act

Behind the financial motivations, Alonso faces a sporting conundrum. After Carlo Ancelotti’s departure, the new manager must not only secure victories but also discover a formation that allows marquee stars like Kylian Mbappe, Vinicius Jr., and Jude Bellingham to thrive simultaneously. Whether he opts for his preferred 3-4-2-1 or sticks with Madrid’s iconic 4-3-3 remains to be seen.

However, Alonso’s system must extract attacking fluency from a frontline that struggled post-January last season. Madrid’s lack of cohesion in key matches, particularly against Barcelona and Arsenal, exposed deep tactical flaws.

Carreras is seen as a puzzle piece in that rebuild — capable of bringing width, balance, and defensive assurance on the left flank. Yet Madrid will only complete that puzzle on their own terms.

What Happens Next?

Madrid’s internal timeline places July as the preferred window for finalising Carreras’ arrival. Talks will continue behind closed doors in Florida, but unless Benfica compromise on their rigid stance regarding upfront payments, this saga could stretch well into the European summer.

For now, Los Blancos are playing a waiting game, betting that Benfica’s resolve will soften once the Club World Cup concludes and Real Madrid’s coffers swell.

Read More: How Will Xabi Alonso’s Real Madrid Set Up in the Club World Cup 2025

FAQs