The revolving door of Pakistan cricket coaching has reached unprecedented levels, with the recent appointment of Azhar Mahmood as interim Test coach marking the 10th coaching change in just six years. This alarming pattern of instability has left fans questioning whether the Pakistan Cricket Board (PCB) can provide the consistency needed for international success.
Table of Contents
The Latest Chapter: Azhar Mahmood Steps In
Former all-rounder Azhar Mahmood has been thrust into the spotlight once again, taking over as interim head coach for red-ball cricket. The 50-year-old, who previously served alongside Jason Gillespie’s coaching staff, now finds himself at the helm of a team desperately seeking stability.
Mahmood’s appointment comes with a contract running until 2026, but given Pakistan’s recent history, longevity remains questionable. His first major challenge will be navigating the start of the new World Test Championship cycle, where Pakistan has consistently failed to reach the finals across three attempts.
The Coaching Exodus: When Experience Walks Away
The departure of high-profile coaches Gary Kirsten and Jason Gillespie sent shockwaves through the cricket world. Both internationally respected figures cited “differences with the board” as their reason for leaving, a diplomatic way of highlighting the deeper systematic issues plaguing Pakistan cricket administration.
Kirsten, who had guided India to World Cup glory in 2011, lasted barely months in his role as white-ball coach. Similarly, Gillespie, the former Australian fast bowler with a stellar coaching record, found the environment untenable for long-term success.
Complete Timeline of Pakistan Cricket Coaches (2019-2025)
| Coach | Position | Tenure | Format | Departure Reason |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Misbah-ul-Haq | Head Coach & Chief Selector | 2019-2021 | All Formats | Resigned due to pressure |
| Saqlain Mushtaq | Head Coach | 2021-2023 | All Formats | Contract not renewed |
| Abdur Rehman | Interim Head Coach | 2023 | All Formats | Temporary appointment |
| Grant Bradburn | Head Coach | 2023 | All Formats | Mutual agreement to part ways |
| Mohammed Hafeez | Head Coach & Team Director | 2023-2024 | All Formats | Stepped down |
| Azhar Mahmood | Interim Head Coach | 2024 | All Formats | Temporary role |
| Jason Gillespie | Head Coach | 2024 | Tests Only | Cited differences with PCB |
| Gary Kirsten | Head Coach | 2024 | T20/ODI Only | Cited differences with PCB |
| Aaqib Javed | Interim Head Coach | 2024-2025 | All Formats | Temporary appointment |
| Mike Hesson | Head Coach | 2025-Present | T20/ODI Only | Current white-ball coach |
| Azhar Mahmood | Interim Head Coach | 2025-Present | Tests Only | Current red-ball coach |
The Split Coaching Experiment: Success or Failure?
Pakistan’s decision to adopt separate coaches for different formats initially seemed progressive, mirroring successful models used by other nations. However, the simultaneous departure of both Kirsten and Gillespie exposed fundamental flaws in the system.
The split coaching approach requires exceptional coordination and communication between different coaching staff, player management systems, and administrative support. Pakistan’s inability to maintain these relationships suggests deeper organizational challenges that extend beyond individual coaching appointments.
Impact on Player Development and Team Performance
The constant coaching changes have created a culture of uncertainty that directly impacts player development and team performance. Young cricketers struggle to adapt to different coaching philosophies, tactical approaches, and training methods when leadership changes every few months.
World Test Championship Performance Analysis
| WTC Cycle | Position | Win Percentage | Key Issues |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2019-2021 | 5th | 43.33% | Inconsistent home performances |
| 2021-2023 | 5th | 51.85% | Poor overseas record |
| 2023-2025 | Bottom Half | 33.33% | Multiple coaching changes |
The statistics paint a clear picture: Pakistan’s Test cricket has suffered significantly during this period of coaching instability, with the team failing to reach even the World Test Championship playoffs across three cycles.
Administrative Challenges Behind the Scenes
The frequent coaching changes reflect deeper administrative issues within the PCB. Sources close to the board suggest that unrealistic expectations, interference in team selection, and lack of long-term vision contribute to the revolving door scenario.
International coaches often find themselves caught between board expectations and ground realities, leading to inevitable conflicts. The departure of experienced coaches like Kirsten and Gillespie represents not just individual disappointments but systemic failures in governance.
The Financial Cost of Instability
Each coaching change carries significant financial implications:
- Severance packages for departing coaches
- Recruitment costs for new appointments
- Training program disruptions requiring restarts
- Lost commercial opportunities due to poor performance
The cumulative cost of these changes likely exceeds millions of dollars, money that could have been invested in grassroots development and infrastructure improvement.
Looking Forward: Can Pakistan Break the Cycle?
Breaking this cycle requires fundamental changes in how Pakistan cricket operates. The board must commit to:
- Long-term vision development spanning 3-5 years
- Clear role definitions for coaches and administrators
- Performance metrics beyond immediate results
- Cultural change within the organization
- Player welfare prioritization over short-term gains
The Azhar Mahmood Challenge
Mahmood faces an uphill battle in his interim role. His previous experience as interim coach in 2024 provides some advantage, but the systemic challenges remain unchanged. Success will depend not just on his coaching abilities but on the board’s willingness to provide stability and support.
The upcoming World Test Championship cycle represents a crucial opportunity for Pakistan to demonstrate that they can maintain consistency. However, without addressing the underlying issues that led to previous coaching departures, even the most talented coaches may find themselves part of this unwelcome statistic.
Read More: Smriti Mandhana Becomes First Indian Woman Cricketer With Centuries in All Three Formats
FAQs
Why do Pakistan cricket coaches keep leaving?
The primary reasons include differences with the PCB administration, unrealistic expectations, interference in team selection, and lack of long-term vision from the board.
How does coaching instability affect player performance?
Constant coaching changes disrupt player development, create uncertainty in tactical approaches, and prevent the establishment of consistent training methods and team culture.
What is Pakistan’s record in the World Test Championship?
Pakistan has failed to reach the finals in all three WTC cycles, finishing 5th twice and struggling in the current cycle with multiple coaching changes.
Who was the most successful recent Pakistan cricket coach?
Saqlain Mushtaq had the longest tenure (2021-2023) and achieved a 51.85% win rate in the WTC, but even he couldn’t secure long-term stability.
What needs to change for Pakistan cricket coaching stability?
The PCB needs to develop a long-term vision, reduce administrative interference, set realistic expectations, and create a supportive environment for coaches to succeed.
This analysis of Pakistan cricket’s coaching instability highlights the urgent need for systematic reform. Only through addressing these fundamental issues can Pakistan hope to achieve the consistency required for international success.
