When Selena Gomez and Benny Blanco exchanged vows in an intimate September 2025 ceremony, Only Murders in the Building co-star Martin Short became an unexpected part of the couple’s memorable moments—for all the wrong reasons. Here’s the hilarious story of how he accidentally “performed surgery” on the wedding cake.
Table of Contents
Selena Gomez Wedding Facts
| Detail | Information |
|---|---|
| Couple | Selena Gomez & Benny Blanco |
| Wedding Date | September 27, 2025 |
| Ceremony Type | Private, Intimate |
| Notable Guests | Ed Sheeran, Taylor Swift, Paul Rudd, Martin Short, Steve Martin |
| Cake Incident Culprit | Martin Short |
| Cake Status | Surgically Repaired |
The Innocent Mistake That Went Viral
During his recent appearance on Jimmy Kimmel Live!, the 75-year-old comedy legend recounted the embarrassing moment with his signature humor. Seated at a table with Paul Rudd and his wife Julie during the reception, Short spotted what he believed was a dessert cake placed nearby.
As his co-star Steve Martin prepared to leave early, Short decided to be thoughtful. “You can’t leave yet without a piece of wedding cake,” he recalled telling Martin. Armed with a fork, he proceeded to cut into the cake from both sides, completely unaware of what was about to unfold.
The Moment of Realization
The reaction was immediate and dramatic. Guests around him erupted in panic, screaming to stop him. That’s when the devastating truth hit—Short had just sliced into THE wedding cake that Selena and Benny were supposed to cut together as their first official act as a married couple.
“I had a fork in my hand,” Short explained sheepishly, recounting how he even attempted to fix his mistake with the same fork, only making things worse. His solution? Leave immediately and hope nobody tells the bride for at least a month.
The Emergency Cake Surgery
Fortunately, the wedding team sprang into action. The wedding coordinator was called, followed by the chef, who performed what Short hilariously described as “surgery” on the cake. “They did surgery, but it ended up being like a Hollywood wedding cake,” he joked on the show, adding, “it was beautiful, but now it had a little work done.”
The reference to plastic surgery perfectly captured the comedic essence of the situation—the cake had literally received a cosmetic makeover to hide the damage.
Selena’s Reaction Remains a Mystery
Interestingly, neither Selena Gomez nor Benny Blanco have publicly commented on the cake incident. Given their close working relationship on Only Murders in the Building, fans speculate the couple likely found the mishap more amusing than upsetting.
For fans wanting more behind-the-scenes moments from the wedding, explore our Hollywood celebrity weddings coverage for exclusive updates.
The Star-Studded Guest List
The private ceremony brought together some of entertainment’s biggest names. Ed Sheeran, Taylor Swift, Paul Rudd, and the entire Only Murders in the Building family including Martin Short and Steve Martin witnessed the couple’s vows.
Selena wore a custom Ralph Lauren creation while Benny looked dapper in a classic tuxedo. The intimate affair reflected the couple’s preference for privacy despite their high-profile careers.
Check out more celebrity wedding stories and behind-the-scenes moments from your favorite stars.
Why This Story Resonates
Martin Short’s cake catastrophe perfectly captures why fans love the Only Murders in the Building cast. The genuine friendship between Selena, Martin, and Steve Martin extends far beyond their on-screen chemistry, creating authentic moments that feel more like family than Hollywood colleagues.
The incident also showcases Short’s endearing personality—his willingness to share embarrassing stories demonstrates the comfort level within this tight-knit group. For more hilarious celebrity moments and entertainment news, visit our dedicated section.
FAQs
Did Martin Short really ruin Selena Gomez’s wedding cake?
Yes, Martin Short accidentally cut into the official wedding cake before the couple, mistaking it for a regular dessert, but the chef performed emergency repairs to restore it.
How did Selena Gomez and Benny Blanco react to the cake incident?
Neither Selena Gomez nor Benny Blanco have publicly commented on Martin Short’s cake mishap, though they’ve remained tight-lipped about the entire ordeal.
