Top 5 Football Superstars Who Almost Signed for ISL Clubs: The Ones That Got Away

The Indian Super League has successfully attracted legendary foreign players throughout its history, from Alessandro Del Piero to Robert Pires and Roberto Carlos, bringing global excitement to Indian football. However, the league’s pursuit of world-class talent has not always succeeded, with several elite footballers coming remarkably close to joining ISL franchises before circumstances prevented the moves. This examination of five football superstars who almost signed for ISL clubs reveals the near-misses that could have fundamentally transformed Indian football’s trajectory.

Top 5 Superstars Who Almost Joined ISL

1. Andrea Pirlo – The FIFA World Cup Winner

Andrea Pirlo stands as perhaps the greatest midfielder to emerge from Italian football, with a legendary career spanning over two decades. The Italian maestro won six Serie A titles with both AC Milan and Juventus, captured the UEFA Champions League twice, and won the FIFA World Cup with Italy in 2006. His exceptional technical qualities, flair on the ball, and midfield dominance established him as one of football’s all-time greats.

Remarkably, an unspecified ISL club actively pursued Pirlo for the league’s second edition in 2015, a time when the midfielder had just departed Juventus. Pirlo was reportedly open to the possibility of playing in Indian football and experiencing the ISL environment. However, the ISL’s mandatory salary cap regulations presented an insurmountable obstacle, with the league’s financial restrictions preventing compensation at Pirlo’s elite-level expectations.

Had the salary cap not existed, Indian football fans could have witnessed the legendary midfielder grace the league with his incomparable magic before he eventually joined New York City FC for his final playing years.

2. Julio Baptista – The Brazilian Powerhouse

Julio Baptista earned his reputation as a hard-working, explosive midfielder capable of delivering goals and assists at the highest levels. The Brazilian international was a multiple Copa America winner with Brazil and achieved La Liga success with Real Madrid during his career across European football’s elite competitions.

In 2017, Kerala Blasters identified Baptista as a transformational signing who could deliver immediate impact and help the franchise capture the ISL title. The Blasters’ management believed Baptista’s physical profile and stature could dominate ISL competition while contributing substantially through goals and assists. At the time, Baptista was available as a free agent after departing Orlando City and appeared positioned for an Indian football opportunity.

However, Baptista was simultaneously negotiating with Bolton Wanderers, ultimately prioritizing the English club opportunity over the Kerala Blasters proposal. Ironically, Bolton never completed the signing, leaving both Baptista and Kerala Blasters frustrated as the deal evaporated.

3. Stiliyan Petrov – The Bulgarian Legend

Stiliyan Petrov holds the distinction of being Bulgaria’s highest-capped player with 105 international appearances, establishing legendary status within Bulgarian football. The midfielder enjoyed a memorable stint with Celtic in the early 2000s before joining Aston Villa, developing a reputation as a hard-working, gritty competitor who excelled in winning duels and troubling opponents through relentless effort.

Petrov’s career faced significant interruption when he battled leukaemia in 2012, subsequently entering remission. Aston Villa supported him through his health crisis, though the club released him in 2013. After overcoming leukaemia a second time, Petrov attempted a comeback in 2017, practicing with Aston Villa and attracting an ISL club’s interest.

Despite receiving a concrete ISL offer, Petrov ultimately declined, explaining that returning to professional football in his late 30s in the Indian Super League did not align with his personal priorities and career objectives.

4. Rickie Lambert – The Southampton Sensation

Rickie Lambert earned his reputation as a clinical forward through outstanding performances with Southampton in the early 2010s, culminating in a transfer to Liverpool. His exceptional 2013-14 campaign produced 13 goals and 10 assists in the Premier League, earning him selection to England’s 2014 FIFA World Cup squad. However, his Liverpool career deteriorated significantly, with the striker managing only two Premier League goals for the Reds.

Following his release from Cardiff City at the end of the 2016-17 season, Kerala Blasters pursued Lambert as a potential impact signing for Indian football. The Englishman’s pedigree and proven goalscoring ability attracted the Blasters’ management, who believed he could contribute substantially to their championship ambitions.

However, Lambert ultimately rejected the ISL opportunity and chose retirement instead. In October 2017, the forward officially retired from professional football rather than pursue an Indian football opportunity with Kerala Blasters.

5. Mario Balotelli – The Controversial Talent

Mario Balotelli remains one of the 21st century’s most controversial footballers, having played for Inter Milan and Manchester City while earning a Premier League title and exceptional Euro 2012 performances. Despite his undeniable talent, disciplinary issues consistently undermined his career progression, relegating the Italian forward to football’s periphery.

In 2024, Kerala Blasters held discussions with Balotelli regarding a potential ISL move, with his representatives meeting Blasters management to explore the possibility. Balotelli expressed openness to experiencing Indian football and joining the ISL.

However, the deal ultimately collapsed when the Blasters’ management determined that Balotelli’s wage demands exceeded their budget allocation. Additionally, the club remained concerned about his historical disciplinary problems and potential negative impact on squad culture and stability. Had the wage structure accommodated Balotelli and the club’s management overlooked disciplinary concerns, ISL defenders could have faced the controversial Italian’s offensive prowess during the 2024-25 season.

What Could Have Been

Each of these five superstars represented transformational opportunities for the ISL. Pirlo’s technical mastery, Baptista’s explosiveness, Petrov’s midfield grit, Lambert’s goalscoring prowess, and Balotelli’s controversial talent could have elevated Indian football’s global profile and competitive standards. The circumstances preventing these signings—salary caps, competing opportunities, personal preference, retirement decisions, and budget constraints—reveal the complex dynamics governing elite player recruitment.

Read More: Xabi Alonso Departs Real Madrid After 7-Month Tenure Following Barcelona Super Cup Loss

FAQs