The IPL auction has always been a spectacle of unexpected turns, where rising stars are catapulted into the limelight while seasoned players face surprising setbacks. This year’s event in Jeddah, which concluded on November 25, was no exception.
While young Vaibhav Suryavanshi created history by becoming the youngest player to secure a contract, Prithvi Shaw’s unsold status raised eyebrows, sparking debates about talent, form, and the unforgiving nature of the sport.
Table of Contents
The Curious Case of Prithvi Shaw
Prithvi Shaw’s fall from grace is a story of raw potential overshadowed by unmet expectations. Hailed as a prodigy after his stellar performances at the U-19 level and a century on his Test debut at 18, Shaw was often compared to legends like Sachin Tendulkar. However, his career trajectory has veered into a cautionary tale, drawing parallels with Vinod Kambli’s narrative of unfulfilled promise.
Ricky Ponting, former Delhi Capitals (DC) coach, expressed his disappointment. “Sad,” he remarked, reflecting on Shaw’s immense talent. “I still say now he is as talented a player as I probably ever worked with. He goes unsold in the auction and then doesn’t even come back in the accelerator.” His absence from DC’s XI for six games last season, reportedly due to disciplinary issues, and subsequent exclusion from the Mumbai Ranji team due to fitness concerns have painted a grim picture of the once-promising star.
Indiscipline and Fitness: The Lingering Concerns
Shaw’s journey has been marred by off-field issues that have gradually impacted his career. Franchises are wary of players who exhibit inconsistent dedication to their fitness and discipline. A source close to the auction process hinted that such factors weigh heavily on decision-making. “When you look at something like that, it’s actually quite sad,” Ponting added, his disappointment underscoring the gravity of Shaw’s situation.
The dynamic nature of the IPL demands players who can not only perform consistently but also adapt to evolving team strategies and expectations. Shaw’s inability to align with these requirements may have contributed to his exclusion.
Changing Priorities: The Six-Hitting Revolution
In the modern T20 landscape, the emphasis has shifted towards power hitters who can consistently clear the boundary. A senior franchise coach explained the prevailing mindset: “The ability to hit sixes is now paramount — it’s 120 in 6 overs which is the high bar now set. Teams are looking for players who have the skill to achieve that.” Shaw, whose game is rooted in classical stroke play rather than brute power, may not align with this new template.
Additionally, franchises prioritize batters capable of attacking from the first ball and bowlers who excel in either taking wickets or delivering defensively consistent spells. Shaw’s recent performances have not matched these exacting standards, further diminishing his appeal.
Broader Implications: A Changing Auction Dynamic
The auction also saw other established names like Shardul Thakur, Kane Williamson, and David Warner go unsold. Ricky Ponting’s reflection on Thakur’s unsold status highlights the evolving dynamics. “Shardul, only a couple of years ago, I think we paid about INR 10 crores for him in an auction. And now he’s not. Now he’s unsold.” The introduction of the Impact Player rule, which reduces the necessity of all-rounders, coupled with high base prices, may have contributed to these trends.
Shaw’s exclusion, however, feels more personal—a reminder that cricket is as much about potential as it is about consistency and professionalism.
Hope for Redemption
Despite the setback, all is not lost for Prithvi Shaw. His talent remains undeniable, as noted by experts and former coaches. The IPL is a platform known for comebacks, and Shaw has the tools to rewrite his narrative. A focus on fitness, discipline, and adapting his game to modern T20 demands could pave the way for his resurgence.
As Ricky Ponting aptly put it, “The game catches up with you.” For Shaw, this could mean a fresh opportunity to recalibrate, learn from his experiences, and once again prove why he was once regarded as one of India’s brightest cricketing stars.
Read More: IPL 2025 Mega Auction Roundup: How the Ten Teams Line Up After the Mega Auction
FAQs
Why was Prithvi Shaw unsold in the IPL 2025 Auction?
Due to inconsistent form, disciplinary issues, and lack of six-hitting ability.
What did Ricky Ponting say about Prithvi Shaw being unsold in the IPL 2025 Auction?
Ricky Ponting expressed disappointment, calling Shaw “as talented a player as I probably ever worked with,” but noted his struggles with discipline and fitness.
What affected Prithvi Shaw’s career?
Once hailed as a prodigy, Shaw’s career has stagnated due to off-field issues and recent fitness concerns. His exclusion from the Mumbai Ranji team and IPL XI last season highlights his struggles.
What qualities are IPL franchises prioritizing in auctions?
IPL franchises now focus on players with exceptional six-hitting ability, consistency, and adaptability to modern T20 strategies.
