Austin Butler’s Overlooked Thriller ‘Caught Stealing’ Gets Netflix Redemption on November 29

Darren Aronofsky’s action-packed crime thriller “Caught Stealing” is getting a second life on Netflix US starting November 29, 2025. Despite earning an impressive 84% Certified Fresh rating on Rotten Tomatoes, the Austin Butler and Zoë Kravitz starrer struggled theatrically—but streaming could be its saving grace.

Caught Stealing: Movie at a Glance

Why Theaters Missed the Mark

Released during the competitive Labor Day weekend, the film earned just over $31.1 million against its $40 million budget, making it a financial disappointment despite critical praise. However, the film found recognition when it became available to purchase digitally and sat in the top ten for iTunes movie rentals, suggesting strong viewer interest beyond the big screen.

The November 29 Netflix date arrives earlier than Sony’s typical 120-day theatrical window, giving the film a rapid path to reach broader audiences.

For comprehensive streaming updates, check our Netflix news hub.

The Story: One Cat, Endless Chaos

The film follows New York City bartender Hank (Butler) as he’s caught in the middle of a gang war after his punk-rock neighbor Russ (Matt Smith) asks him to watch his apartment and cat. What starts as a simple favor spirals into a violent chase through 1990s New York involving Russian mobsters, corrupt cops, and dangerous criminals all searching for something Hank unknowingly possesses.

Based on Charlie Huston’s acclaimed 2004 crime novel, Aronofsky delivers his signature intense storytelling mixed with dark comedy and relentless action—a departure from his typically darker psychological fare.

Explore more action thrillers in our movies section.

Critical Acclaim Despite Box Office Woes

With an 84% Rotten Tomatoes rating, critics have stated the movie is “wickedly entertaining” and “brings joy, thrills, genuine surprises, fantastic performances, and just enough heartbreak”. Time Out called it “decently entertaining,” while reviewers particularly highlighted Butler’s charismatic performance.

The ensemble cast delivers powerhouse performances, with Matt Smith stealing scenes as the punk-rock neighbor, Kravitz adding emotional depth, and even Bad Bunny making a memorable appearance. The film premiered in Puerto Rico during his sold-out concert residency.

Butler’s Dramatic Transformation

Austin Butler underwent another physical metamorphosis for this role. The actor gained 35 pounds in six months, going from 150 to 185 pounds by eating massive amounts of beer and pizza, continuing his pattern of dedication seen in “Elvis” and “Dune: Part Two.”

Stay updated on celebrity transformations through our entertainment news.

Netflix’s Quick Acquisition

After landing on Netflix US, the movie will remain available for 18 months before shifting to Hulu and Disney+ in late May 2027. This rapid streaming release represents Netflix’s strategy of capitalizing on theatrically underperforming films with strong critical reception.

Note that the film won’t be available on Netflix’s ad-supported tier—subscribers need standard or premium plans to watch.

Global Streaming Timeline

India tends to receive Sony titles around the same time as the United States, although most other countries pick them up between two and four years after theatrical release. The United Kingdom is expected to receive Caught Stealing sometime in early to mid-2027.

For complete details, visit the official Netflix page or check IMDb’s Caught Stealing listing.

Will Streaming Change Its Fate?

Given the film’s strong word-of-mouth, critical acclaim, and Butler’s rising star power, “Caught Stealing” has excellent potential to find its audience on Netflix. The platform’s global reach could transform this box office disappointment into a streaming success story, potentially opening doors for adaptations of Charlie Huston’s remaining novels in the Hank Thompson trilogy.

Discover more hidden gems in our streaming recommendations.

Frequently Asked Questions