Zack Ryder’s surprise SmackDown return on November 14 drew 1.158 million viewers, reminding everyone why the Long Island native should have been featured more prominently during his original WWE tenure. Wrestling industry veterans are now questioning how badly the company mishandled one of its most organically over talents.
Table of Contents
Matt Cardona Return That Broke the Internet
| Detail | Information |
|---|---|
| Return Date | November 14, 2024 (SmackDown) |
| Character Used | Zack Ryder (Not Matt Cardona) |
| Opponent | LA Knight |
| Tournament | John Cena’s “Last Time Is Now” |
| Current Status | One-Time Appearance, Merch Deal Only |
| Merchandise Impact | Three shirts became top sellers instantly |
Cardona called the return “the most stressful week of his life” and revealed taking the WWE call during a live podcast recording, having to make up a story to step away. The veteran had gear rushed in 24 hours and was kept hidden in a private room before his entrance.
Why Veterans Say WWE Wasted Him
John Cena praised Ryder’s growth, saying he’s “accrued so much sports entertainment wisdom” since leaving WWE. The 16-time champion’s endorsement highlights what the company lost when they relegated Ryder to undercard status.
The original Ryder Revolution proved he could get himself over without company support. His YouTube series “Z! True Long Island Story” revolutionized how wrestlers could connect with fans directly, predating the modern social media era. WWE responded by burying him after his Internet Championship reign.
What He Accomplished Outside WWE: Cardona captured world championships for NWA, GCW, HOG and JCW after reinventing himself as the most successful independent wrestler in the industry. His indie run proved the talent was always there—WWE just refused to capitalize on it.
The Numbers Don’t Lie
The immediate merchandise sales tell the real story. WWE Shop released three new Zack Ryder shirts that quickly landed among the platform’s top sellers, proving fans still wanted to support him five years after his release.
SmackDown’s ratings boost during his appearance demonstrates the drawing power WWE consistently overlooked. When given proper presentation and his authentic character, Ryder delivered results both at the box office and in merchandise sales.
Breaking the “Zack Ryder Is Dead” Promise
Cardona previously claimed Zack Ryder “needed to die” in an April 2024 Instagram post, stating his indie years had been “the most successful of my career”. His willingness to resurrect the character for this tournament speaks to the emotional significance of returning to WWE.
Some fans criticized the decision to use Zack Ryder instead of Matt Cardona. However, Ryder responded by saying critics “are not a real fan” and that true supporters “got it” and were happy for the moment.
The choice made business sense. Zack Ryder carries nostalgia and WWE history that resonates with the company’s audience. Matt Cardona represents his indie success but lacks the same emotional connection for casual WWE viewers.
The Contract Situation
Fightful Select confirmed Ryder isn’t signed to a WWE contract—the appearance was a one-off for the tournament with a merchandise deal in place. This arrangement lets both parties test the waters without long-term commitment.
Cardona confirmed Friday’s appearance was a “one-time thing” and he signed an agreement to allow WWE to sell merchandise temporarily. The door remains open for future collaborations if both sides see value in continuing the relationship.
What This Means for WWE’s Talent Development
Ryder’s story exemplifies WWE’s historic problem with homegrown talent who get themselves over organically. When wrestlers succeed outside the company’s prescribed formula, they often face pushback rather than support.
His indie success and this triumphant return expose how much potential WWE left on the table. The company had someone who could:
- Generate merchandise sales without prompting
- Connect authentically with audiences
- Create viral content naturally
- Work a safe, reliable match style
For comprehensive WWE coverage, explore our Last Time Is Now tournament breakdown and John Cena retirement tour schedule.
Visit WWE’s official website for complete SmackDown results and upcoming event information.
Could He Return Full-Time?
It’s unclear whether Ryder’s SmackDown return means more WWE appearances are on the way, though his wife Chelsea Green is currently signed with WWE where she’s a double champion. The family connection creates natural storyline opportunities if both parties agree.
SmackDown’s return to three hours in January creates roster space that Cardona could fill. His versatility as both a serious competitor and comedic character provides booking flexibility that modern WWE values.
The wrestling industry has changed significantly since 2020. Independent wrestlers now command respect and negotiating power that didn’t exist during Ryder’s original run. If he returns, it would likely be on much better terms.
The Bigger Picture
Wrestling veterans criticizing WWE’s handling of Zack Ryder aren’t simply being nostalgic. They’re highlighting a systemic issue where the company struggles to support talent who doesn’t fit predetermined molds.
Ryder’s indie success proved he had star power WWE never properly utilized. His one-night return demonstrated that power still exists. The question now is whether WWE learned from its mistakes or will continue wasting organic talent.
The Ryder Resurrection reminded everyone what could have been. Maybe, just maybe, there’s still time for what should be.
Frequently Asked Questions
Why did Matt Cardona return as Zack Ryder instead of using his current name?
Cardona chose to return as Zack Ryder for several strategic reasons. The character carries significant nostalgia and WWE history that resonates with longtime fans who remember his Internet Championship run and YouTube series. While he previously stated Zack Ryder was “dead,” the opportunity to appear in John Cena’s final tournament was emotionally significant enough to warrant reviving the persona. WWE also likely preferred the familiar character name for casual viewers unfamiliar with his indie work as Matt Cardona. The merchandise deal WWE secured only works with recognizable branding, making Zack Ryder the logical business choice despite his indie success under his real name.
Is Zack Ryder coming back to WWE full-time after this appearance?
No, Cardona confirmed this was a one-time appearance specifically for the Last Time Is Now tournament. He’s not currently under a WWE in-ring contract—only a temporary merchandise agreement that allows WWE to sell Zack Ryder products. However, the door isn’t completely closed for future appearances. With SmackDown expanding to three hours in January 2025 and his wife Chelsea Green actively wrestling for the company, opportunities could arise for additional collaborations. WWE sources indicated they’re open to working with him again if the right situation presents itself. For now, Cardona continues wrestling for TNA and on the independent circuit as Matt Cardona while maintaining his successful indie career he’s built since 2020.
