The Whistles of the Bernabeu: From Mbappe to Ronaldo, Decoding Why Real Madrid Fans Don’t Shy Away From Showing Their Discontent

Real Madrid’s prestigious Bernabéu stadium has seen legendary footballers grace its pitch, from Kylian Mbappé to Cristiano Ronaldo. However, a surprising occurrence often arises: the fans whistle their own players. These whistleblasts, synonymous with disapproval, have caused quite a stir over the years. But why does this happen? Why, despite being some of the world’s most talented athletes, do Real Madrid’s stars get booed by their own supporters?

The Demands of Playing for Real Madrid

Real Madrid’s fanbase is legendary, known for its unwavering expectations and a thirst for constant success. At a club that prides itself on being the best in the world, failure is simply not an option. The whistling phenomenon, observed when even the likes of Kylian Mbappé get targeted, speaks volumes about the pressure players face. Mbappé, a World Cup winner and top scorer for Madrid this season, faced whistles from fans after a tense 1-0 victory against Athletic Club. This was soon after a devastating Champions League exit at the hands of Arsenal, and fans voiced their frustration.

However, Mbappé is not alone in facing such treatment. A long list of football legends, including Cristiano Ronaldo, Iker Casillas, and Alfredo Di Stefano, have all felt the sting of the Bernabéu’s disapproval. The reasons behind this harsh treatment raise important questions about the nature of football culture in Madrid.

The Historical Context of Whistling in Spain

To understand why Real Madrid fans whistle their own players, it’s essential to consider Spain’s deep-rooted cultural connection to whistling. In Spain, whistling serves as a form of disapproval, not only in football but in other events, such as bullfighting. Traditionally, if a bullfighter’s performance isn’t up to standard, spectators make their displeasure known with whistles. This cultural element finds its way into football, with the Bernabéu being the stage for some of the most iconic examples of whistling in football history.

Madrid, as Spain’s capital, is a city with a more demanding nature than other regions. The city’s intense desire for success is mirrored in the behaviour of its fans. Whistling at Real Madrid matches has been a regular feature since 1920. In fact, the first notable case of this phenomenon dates back to Madrid’s early years of success in the 1950s, when the team won five consecutive European Cups. During this era, forward Gaspar Rubio faced intense whistles from fans, particularly after he returned from an unauthorised trip to Cuba and Mexico in 1932. His performance on the field, combined with the public backlash, led to him being booed by the crowd.

The Evolution of Whistling: Iconic Legends Under Fire

As Real Madrid’s success grew, so did the scrutiny of its players. One prominent example is Francisco ‘Paco’ Gento, who, despite winning six European Cups, faced early difficulties in Madrid. His incredible speed sometimes left the ball behind, causing frustration among fans when he lost possession. At one point, Madrid even considered sending him back to Racing Santander. However, the legendary Alfredo Di Stefano intervened, vouching for Gento to stay. This episode highlights just how quickly Real Madrid fans can turn on their players, even those who eventually achieve greatness.

Even Di Stefano himself, Real Madrid’s all-time top scorer until Ronaldo, Raul, and Benzema overtook him, wasn’t immune to the pressure of the Bernabéu. In December 1962, a controversial advertising campaign depicting Di Stefano with a woman’s legs and stockings sparked outrage among Spanish society, which was under the dictatorship of General Franco at the time. Despite Madrid paying a hefty fine to halt the campaign, Di Stefano was met with boos when he next took to the field. His response? He scored two decisive goals in a thrilling 3-2 win against Athletic Club, showing that while the whistles stung, they couldn’t deter him.

Media Pressure and High Expectations

Jorge Valdano, a former Real Madrid player and manager, explains the underlying psychological pressures that come with playing at Madrid. According to him, the intense media scrutiny creates an atmosphere where players are constantly under the spotlight. Valdano, now a pundit, recalls how, during his playing days in the 1980s, the weight of expectation at Real Madrid was so heavy that sometimes, returning to Argentina felt like a relief.

Valdano said, “While I was playing for Madrid, sometimes going to Argentina felt like a relief. It’s not that in Argentina I didn’t have any demands, but the pressure at Madrid was unlike anything else. You’re always in a permanent state of alert.” This constant pressure, he notes, leads to a situation where players often feel they are playing in self-defense, constantly battling criticism and the ever-present threat of boos.

This pressure also affected Michel Gonzalez, another Madrid legend from the ‘Quinta del Buitre’ generation, a group of homegrown players who dominated Spanish football in the 1980s. After a crushing 6-1 loss to Milan in the European Cup semi-finals, Michel faced harsh criticism from fans. He became so disheartened that, during a game against Espanyol in June 1989, he left the pitch in protest. He later explained, “When I go to football, I go to enjoy myself. The day of Espanyol, I couldn’t take it anymore.”

The Psychological Impact of Whistling

Psychologist Sara Martinez de Espejo provides insight into why fans engage in such behaviour. She argues that whistling is a psychological tool used by fans to exert influence over players. “A mirror effect is created with idols of the past,” she says. “Fans expect current players to meet the high standards set by previous legends. When players fall short, frustration arises, and whistling becomes a form of psychological pressure.”

The fans’ belief that they can impact the game through such disapproval creates an intense psychological battle for players. The pressure to perform at the highest level, with constant reminders of past successes, can lead to anticipatory anxiety. This is when players, fearing the disapproval of the fans, begin to doubt their own abilities and become emotionally distanced from the game.

Cristiano Ronaldo and Gareth Bale: Superstars Under Fire

Even Cristiano Ronaldo, Real Madrid’s all-time top scorer, faced the brunt of the Bernabéu’s wrath. During a 2017 match against Real Sociedad, Ronaldo was whistled after miscontrolling a ball. His frustration was evident, and he was caught on camera calling fans “Filhos de p***” in Portuguese. This incident showed how even the greatest players can be affected by the hostile atmosphere at the Bernabéu. Ronaldo did, however, respond in true champion fashion, scoring and assisting in a 3-0 win.

Gareth Bale, another marquee signing, also experienced the wrath of the Bernabéu during his nine-year tenure at the club. His relationship with Madrid fans grew increasingly sour, particularly after a high-profile world-record move in 2013. In 2022, former Madrid midfielder Casemiro remarked that the fans were “whistling at the history of this club” when they targeted Bale. Bale himself admitted that the constant whistling hurt, saying, “You would expect your fans to get behind you… but they just whistle you, which makes you feel worse.”

Jose Mourinho and Iker Casillas: Managers and Legends in the Line of Fire

Even managers like Jose Mourinho weren’t spared from the intense scrutiny of the Bernabéu faithful. During his time at the club, Mourinho often found himself at odds with the fans. His relationship with the ultras soured after an infamous incident in which he was whistled during a match against Athletic Club. When Mourinho faced chants from the fans, he famously said, “Zidane has been whistled here, Ronaldo (Nazario) and Cristiano Ronaldo have been whistled here. Why can’t I be whistled?” His defiant response underlined the fact that, at Real Madrid, no one is beyond reproach.

Legendary goalkeeper Iker Casillas, too, faced hostility from the fans. During the 2014-15 season, Casillas found himself constantly whistled at, especially after a disappointing 2-2 draw against Valencia. In an emotional moment captured on Spanish TV, Casillas responded, “Whistle whatever you want, for f***’s sake.” Despite being one of Madrid’s greatest players, his deteriorating relationship with coach Mourinho and the media led to growing criticism from fans.

Pressure for Success: Real Madrid’s Current Dilemma

The pressure at Madrid continues to be intense. This season, after a humbling 5-2 loss to Barcelona in the Supercopa de España final, coach Carlo Ancelotti, midfielder Aurelien Tchouameni, and right-back Lucas Vazquez were all whistled during their next match. Even Vinicius Jr, a rising star at Madrid, was targeted during a 1-1 draw with Valencia. The growing dissatisfaction stems from the high expectations placed on the team, compounded by the monumental €1.76 billion renovation of the Bernabéu.

For current stars like Mbappé, the situation is no different. Despite being one of the most sought-after players in world football, Mbappé has faced repeated whistles from the crowd, especially after Madrid’s Champions League exit to Arsenal. The psychological toll on players, as Martinez de Espejo explains, can lead to self-doubt, although some players, like Mbappé, manage to rise above it.

Read More: Carlo Ancelotti and Real Madrid Seal Exit Pact as Brazil Awaits Iconic Manager

FAQs