Why BCCI Chose Shreyas Iyer Over KL Rahul as ODI Vice-Captain

When the Board of Control for Cricket in India announced the squads for the Australia tour on October 4, 2025, most eyes fixated on Shubman Gill replacing Rohit Sharma as ODI captain. Yet buried within that headline was an equally significant revelation: Shreyas Iyer had been appointed vice-captain, effectively leapfrogging KL Rahul in the leadership hierarchy despite both wicketkeepers being part of the squad. This wasn’t merely a squad selection—it was a statement of intent, a glimpse into the BCCI’s vision for Indian cricket’s post-Rohit era.

The Announcement That Changed Everything

The 15-member ODI squad for Australia featured familiar faces—Rohit Sharma, Virat Kohli, KL Rahul, and Yashasvi Jaiswal—but the power structure had fundamentally shifted. Gill wore the captain’s armband, while Shreyas Iyer secured the vice-captaincy designation that many assumed would default to the experienced Rahul.

The move sparked immediate debate. Shreyas Iyer, who turns 31 in December, earned the vice-captaincy role despite being neither the most experienced nor the most capped player in the squad. Meanwhile, KL Rahul—two years Iyer’s senior and possessing established international captaincy credentials—found himself relegated to wicketkeeper duties without leadership responsibilities.

Shreyas Iyer’s Compelling Credentials

To understand the BCCI’s decision, one must examine Shreyas Iyer’s remarkable leadership journey across formats and competitions. His captaincy resume reads like a masterclass in versatile leadership:

IPL Success Across Multiple Franchises

Shreyas Iyer became one of cricket’s rare leaders who succeeded with multiple IPL franchises. At just 24, he captained Delhi Capitals to their maiden IPL final in 2020, showcasing tactical maturity beyond his years. After injuries derailed his progress, he returned stronger, leading Kolkata Knight Riders to their third IPL title in 2024. That same year, he guided Mumbai to the Syed Mushtaq Ali Trophy.

Most impressively, in IPL 2025, Shreyas Iyer captained Punjab Kings to their second-ever IPL final, finishing as one of the tournament’s premier batsmen with 604 runs in 17 matches at a blistering strike rate of 175.07. His ability to perform under pressure while managing diverse personalities established him as a genuine leader, not just a placeholder captain.

Champions Trophy Heroics

The 2025 Champions Trophy represented Shreyas Iyer’s coming-of-age tournament. He emerged as India’s highest run-scorer with 243 runs—ahead of established stars like Virat Kohli, Rohit Sharma, and Shubman Gill. His century against New Zealand in the semi-finals showcased his ability to deliver when stakes reached their zenith. The ICC recognized his brilliance by naming him Men’s Player of the Month twice—in February and March 2025.

Current Form and Preparation

Leading up to the Australia tour announcement, Shreyas Iyer captained India A in a three-match ODI series against Australia A, demonstrating the BCCI’s confidence in his leadership trajectory. He scored 110 runs off 83 deliveries in the first ODI and followed up with 62 runs off 58 balls in the third match, maintaining consistency that reinforced his selection credentials.

The KL Rahul Paradox

KL Rahul’s omission from vice-captaincy consideration presents a fascinating case study in how Indian cricket evaluates leadership. On paper, his credentials appear formidable:

International Captaincy Experience

KL Rahul has captained India across formats with respectable results:

• ODIs: 12 matches, 8 wins (66.67% win rate)
• Tests: 3 matches, 2 wins (66.67% win rate)
• T20Is: 1 match, 1 win (100% win rate)

He became India’s 34th Test captain in January 2022 and led the team to a 2-0 series victory against Bangladesh in December 2022. His ODI captaincy debut came against South Africa, and despite an initial 3-0 series loss, he subsequently guided India to victories against Zimbabwe and Bangladesh.

IPL Leadership: The Damning Evidence

Yet KL Rahul’s IPL captaincy record reveals why the BCCI looked elsewhere. Across 64 matches leading Punjab Kings (2020-2021) and Lucknow Super Giants (2022-2023), he managed only a 50% win rate—32 victories from 64 games. Under his captaincy, Punjab Kings finished sixth in both 2020 and 2021. While LSG reached playoffs in both seasons he led them (2022-2023), the franchise ultimately decided not to retain him, and Delhi Capitals acquired him purely as a player for IPL 2025.

The stark contrast in trophy cabinets speaks volumes. Shreyas Iyer has proven he can win—and win across different team cultures and playing conditions. KL Rahul, despite individual brilliance, hasn’t translated leadership opportunities into silverware.

The BCCI’s Strategic Calculation

The selection of Shreyas Iyer as vice-captain represents sophisticated succession planning that extends beyond immediate tour requirements.

Future-Proofing Indian Cricket

At 31, Shreyas Iyer sits in the sweet spot—young enough to captain India through the 2027 Cricket World Cup and beyond, yet experienced enough to command respect immediately. With Rohit Sharma nearing career’s end in ODI cricket, the BCCI needs leaders who can bridge the transition from the Rohit-Kohli era to the next generation.

A BCCI source told Indian Express in June 2025: “Right now he just plays ODIs but after this IPL we can’t keep him out of T20 internationals and even Tests. Plus, he also has now officially joined the white-ball captaincy race.”

Tactical Acumen and Pressure Management

Shreyas Iyer’s leadership style emphasizes aggressive yet calculated cricket—perfectly aligned with modern limited-overs requirements. His ability to manage big personalities (evident from handling star-studded IPL squads) and make bold tactical calls has impressed selectors. Unlike some captains who become conservative under pressure, Iyer maintains attacking intent while reading match situations astutely.

The Karma Narrative

There’s poetic justice in Shreyas Iyer’s elevation. After being controversially excluded from India’s T20 Asia Cup 2025 squad despite stellar form, and having lost his BCCI central contract in February 2024 for missing Ranji Trophy matches, his resilience tells a redemption story the board values. He responded to adversity by dominating domestic cricket (averaging 68.57 in Ranji Trophy with a double century), excelling in the Champions Trophy, and leading Punjab Kings superbly in IPL 2025.

What This Means for KL Rahul

KL Rahul’s demotion from vice-captaincy contention doesn’t diminish his importance to Indian cricket, but it clarifies his role: elite specialist batsman and wicketkeeper, not future captain.

At 33, KL Rahul remains invaluable for his batting versatility and wicketkeeping excellence. His Champions Trophy 2025 contributions were crucial, and his recent Test performances in England (137 at Headingley, 55 at Edgbaston in 2025) prove his continued relevance across formats. However, the BCCI has evidently concluded that his future lies in contributing as a senior player rather than as a leadership candidate.

The decision also reflects harsh realities about IPL performance weighing heavily in BCCI calculations. With franchises consistently choosing not to retain KL Rahul as captain—Punjab Kings moving on after 2021, LSG not retaining him for 2025, and Delhi Capitals hiring him without captaincy responsibilities—the message from domestic cricket’s most competitive environment couldn’t be clearer.

The Bigger Picture: India’s ODI Future

This leadership reshuffle signals the BCCI’s commitment to aggressive generational transition. By installing Gill as captain with Shreyas Iyer as deputy, they’ve created a succession plan that could extend through the 2027 World Cup and beyond.

The choice also demonstrates that the board values proven winners over theoretical credentials. Shreyas Iyer has consistently delivered trophies—something that matters more than individual statistics when evaluating captaincy potential. His tactical intelligence, ability to inspire teammates, and knack for performing in crucial moments make him the natural heir apparent.

For KL Rahul, this decision represents a fork in the road. He can either embrace his role as a world-class specialist and focus on cementing his legacy through performances, or risk fading as younger talents emerge. His response to this setback will define how his career is ultimately remembered.

A Decision That Makes Sense

The BCCI’s appointment of Shreyas Iyer as ODI vice-captain over KL Rahul represents logical, forward-thinking leadership planning. Iyer’s trophy-winning pedigree, current form, tactical maturity, and age profile make him the superior choice for a role ultimately about succession rather than seniority.

While KL Rahul remains an exceptional cricketer whose contributions will be vital, leadership demands qualities beyond individual brilliance. Shreyas Iyer has proven repeatedly—across IPL franchises, domestic tournaments, and international stages—that he possesses the winner’s mentality and tactical acumen required to lead India into its next era.

This wasn’t a slight against Rahul; it was recognition of Iyer’s exceptional credentials. Sometimes, the best decisions aren’t about who deserves recognition, but about who can deliver results when the stakes are highest. In Shreyas Iyer, the BCCI has identified a leader capable of carrying Indian cricket’s standard into the future.

Read More: Hyderabad FC Relocates to Delhi: ISL Champions Begin Fresh Journey as Sporting Club Delhi

FAQs