The music industry is no stranger to battles over group names and trademarks, but when a beloved K-pop group like fromis_9 faces such an ordeal, emotions run high. The girl group, known for its dedicated fanbase and heartfelt music, finds itself in a legal and emotional tug-of-war following their departure from HYBE and Pledis Entertainment. As they attempt to secure their group name, ongoing negotiations have proven difficult, leaving members frustrated and fans outraged.
Recently, fromis_9 members Baek Jiheon and Lee Chaeyoung took to the Instiz app, expressing their disappointment and heartbreak over the struggle to retain their identity. Their candid messages revealed how negotiations have not been smooth, and despite their commitment to staying together, they feel as though their efforts are being dismissed.
The reaction from fans, collectively known as Flovers, has been swift and strong. Social media platforms have been flooded with messages of support and frustration, with many criticizing HYBE and Pledis Entertainment for making it difficult for the group to move forward. As discussions around trademark ownership and industry practices continue, the K-pop world watches closely, hoping for a resolution that honors the hard work and legacy of fromis_9.
Table of Contents
Baek Jiheon and Lee Chaeyoung Speak Out: Members Express Their Frustration
The emotional weight of the situation was evident when Baek Jiheon, one of fromis_9’s vocalists, poured her heart out to fans. In a message shared on Instiz, she revealed how the group’s determination to protect their name was being taken advantage of, leaving them feeling powerless. She emphasized that the battle was never about money but about preserving their identity and artistic legacy.
Similarly, Lee Chaeyoung assured fans that no matter the outcome, the group would stay together. Her message struck a chord with Flovers as she pleaded, “Even if we have to go by a different name, please still love us.” The uncertainty surrounding their future identity as fromis_9 has left both the members and fans deeply unsettled.
HYBE’s Involvement: Why Is the Company Holding Onto the Name?
The controversy has sparked a larger conversation about trademark ownership in K-pop. While fromis_9 was originally formed under CJ ENM’s Stone Music Entertainment, they later transitioned to Pledis Entertainment, a subsidiary of HYBE. However, despite HYBE not being the original creator of the group, they still retain the trademark for the name fromis_9.
Fans have pointed out that this is not the first time HYBE has withheld a group’s name after contract expirations. Similar issues were seen when GFRIEND disbanded in 2021, with the members unable to retain their group name despite their years of work. Now, with fromis_9 facing the same battle, concerns about HYBE’s handling of girl groups continue to grow.
The Legal Battle Over Group Names in K-pop
In the K-pop industry, it is common for agencies to hold legal rights over group names, making it difficult for members to continue under the same identity if they leave the company. This practice, though legally sound, is widely debated due to its impact on artists and their fans.
Many argue that since fromis_9 members actively contributed to building the group’s legacy, they should have the right to keep their name. However, companies often retain these trademarks for potential future use, whether it be reviving the group with new members or rebranding the concept under a different lineup.
Fan Outrage: “What Is HYBE’s Problem?”
The reaction from K-pop fans has been fierce, with many taking to Twitter, Instagram, and fan forums to express their frustration. Some accused HYBE of trying to monopolize the industry, while others pointed out how male groups under the company receive more support than their female counterparts.
One viral tweet read, “HYBE didn’t form the group, barely promoted them, and now they won’t even let them keep their name? Disgraceful.” Another fan lamented, “Not one girl group is safe under HYBE. First GFRIEND, now fromis_9. Who’s next?”
The anger and disappointment have led to calls for boycotts and petitions demanding justice for fromis_9.
A New Name or a Legal Victory: What’s Next for fromis_9?
As it stands, five members—Song Hayoung, Park Jiwon, Lee Nakyoung, Lee Chaeyoung, and Baek Jiheon—have signed with ASND, a new agency, while Lee Saerom, Lee Seoyeon, and Roh Jisun have chosen different paths. However, the battle over the name continues, leaving the future uncertain.
If negotiations fail, fromis_9 may have to rebrand under a new name, similar to how GFRIEND members regrouped as VIVIZ. However, fans remain hopeful for a legal resolution that will allow them to retain their original identity.
Final Thoughts: A Fight for Fairness in K-pop
fromis_9’s struggle to retain their group name is more than just a legal dispute—it’s a fight for identity, recognition, and fairness in the industry. As the members push forward in this battle, their passion and resilience continue to inspire fans worldwide.
While the outcome remains uncertain, one thing is clear: Flovers will stand by them, no matter what name they go by. As this story unfolds, the support from fans and the broader K-pop community will be crucial in ensuring that fromis_9 gets the justice and respect they deserve.
Blackpink Jisoo Teases Fans with Exclusive ‘Newtopia’ Behind-the-Scenes Photos
FAQs
1. Why can’t fromis_9 keep their name after leaving HYBE?
The name “fromis_9” is legally owned by HYBE, meaning the company has the right to control its use. This has made it difficult for the members to retain their original identity despite their years of work.
2. Have other K-pop groups faced similar issues?
Yes, groups like GFRIEND and BEAST have faced similar struggles when trying to retain their names after leaving their original agencies. Some were forced to rebrand, while others fought legal battles to regain their identity.
3. What can fans do to support fromis_9?
Fans can spread awareness, sign petitions, and continue supporting the members regardless of what name they end up using. Staying vocal on social media and advocating for fair treatment can also put pressure on the company.
