Erling Haaland vs Lionel Messi: Statistical Comparison at Age 24

Erling Haaland vs Lionel Messi: At just 24, Erling Haaland is already being compared to some of football’s greatest legends. His phenomenal goal-scoring ability has raised questions about how he stacks up against Lionel Messi at the same age. While both players have achieved remarkable success early in their careers, the contrast in their playing styles and positions makes for a fascinating comparison.

Let’s delve into their records and see how the two stars measure up at the same age.

Haaland’s Incredible Start at Manchester City

Erling Haaland’s move to Manchester City came with high expectations, and he didn’t disappoint. In his debut season, Haaland scored an outstanding 52 goals, helping City clinch the treble, which included winning the Premier League, FA Cup, and UEFA Champions League. His presence in the Premier League was felt immediately, as he dominated defenders with his strength, positioning, and clinical finishing ability.

By the age of 24, Haaland has managed to score 99 goals for Manchester City across all competitions, doing so in just over two seasons. His record is not just impressive but historic. Few players have ever made such an immediate impact on one of the world’s most competitive leagues.

Haaland’s Record-Breaking Goal Tally

Haaland’s ability to score has set him apart from his peers. At 24, the Norwegian has racked up an astounding 256 goals in just 314 professional games, which is remarkable considering the level of competition he’s faced, particularly in leagues like the Bundesliga and Premier League. He is known for scoring a wide variety of goals, from close-range tap-ins to long-range strikes, headers, and everything in between. His natural talent for finding space in the box has allowed him to keep a consistent and incredibly high goal-scoring rate.

A large part of his success comes from his role as an out-and-out striker, a position that allows him to focus solely on getting into goal-scoring positions, a stark contrast to Messi’s early career.

Different Playing Styles and Systems

When comparing Haaland and Messi at the age of 24, it’s important to remember their differences in style. Haaland is a traditional number nine, whose main focus is finishing chances and positioning himself in the best possible place to score. His physical attributes—his height, speed, and strength—give him an edge in set-piece situations and when battling defenders one-on-one. Haaland relies heavily on his ability to outmuscle defenders and get into goal-scoring positions with the help of his teammates.

On the other hand, Messi was more of a complete player even in his younger years. Although he often played on the right wing, Messi would drift inside, take on defenders, and often create goals for both himself and others. His vision and technical ability made him one of the most feared playmakers, while his finishing was still top-notch. Messi’s game was not built solely around scoring goals; it was about dominating the game in multiple ways.

Haaland’s Goal-Scoring Longevity

Despite their differences, Haaland’s current trajectory suggests that he is capable of surpassing Messi’s career goal tally, should he maintain his fitness and form. Haaland’s raw numbers are staggering. At this rate, with his exceptional strike rate and fewer injuries, it’s plausible that he will continue to break records, particularly in terms of total goals scored. His 99 goals for Manchester City in just 104 games indicate that he is a goal machine, capable of maintaining an impressive pace for many seasons to come.

However, the Norwegian striker’s goal-scoring feats depend heavily on remaining injury-free, something that has plagued many players who play with the intensity that Haaland does. If he manages to avoid major injuries, he could well become one of the greatest goalscorers in football history.

Messi’s Achievements by 24

While Haaland has focused primarily on goal-scoring, Messi had already won numerous personal and team accolades by the time he was 24. He had collected three Ballon d’Or trophies (2009, 2010, and 2011), cementing his place as one of the top players in the world. Messi’s contributions went beyond goals, with his vision, dribbling, and passing playing a crucial role in Barcelona’s successes during his early years.

By 24, Messi had already won several La Liga titles and two UEFA Champions League trophies. His role in these triumphs wasn’t solely as a goal-scorer but as a creative force who could change the course of a game with his playmaking ability.

Haaland’s Potential vs Messi’s Legacy

Comparing Haaland and Messi directly at 24 might not be entirely fair because of the differences in their roles and teams. Haaland is a prolific striker who lives to score goals, whereas Messi, in his early years, was much more of a multi-faceted player, influencing all aspects of the game.

At 24, Messi had scored 197 goals in 356 appearances, a lower tally than Haaland, but his contributions went far beyond the score sheet. Messi’s influence on the game involved assisting and drawing defenders away to create space for his teammates, which was just as valuable to Barcelona as his goals.

That being said, Haaland’s goal tally is hard to ignore. His potential to become one of the top all-time goalscorers seems inevitable if he stays healthy. His impressive numbers in the Premier League, a notoriously difficult league for strikers, have already earned him legendary status, and he’s only just entering his prime.

FAQs