Erling Haaland and Kylian Mbappé, donning the number nine shirts, could be the decisive factors in the Champions League How has Kylian Mbappé adapted to Real Madrid’s playing style?clash between Manchester City and Real Madrid.
Table of Contents
The Battle of the Number Nines: Haaland vs Mbappé in a High-Stakes Clash
As Manchester City and Real Madrid prepare for this week’s marquee Champions League showdown, the challenge of containing an elite number nine looms large in both camps.
Despite City’s inconsistent form, Erling Haaland remains the primary threat, while Kylian Mbappé, after a sluggish start at Madrid, has evolved into the superstar they expected when they signed him last summer.
Yet, despite leading the scoring charts for two of the world’s biggest clubs, both strikers have faced scrutiny this season. The weight of the iconic number nine jersey brings immense pressure, compounded by the lofty expectations set by their past goal-scoring feats and silverware hauls.
With both teams struggling this season and forced into a Champions League play-off round, the stakes couldn’t be higher. One of these European giants won’t even reach the last 16, making Haaland and Mbappé’s performances even more crucial in this two-legged battle.
Both clubs have faced challenges in the first half of the 2024-25 season, with their centre-forwards coming under scrutiny despite ranking among Europe’s top scorers.
Despite City’s difficulties, Haaland has remained one of the most consistent goal-scorers in Europe. Among players in the top five leagues, only Robert Lewandowski (30), Harry Kane (28), and Mohamed Salah (26) have netted more across all competitions this season than the City striker (25). Excluding penalties, only Lewandowski (25) surpasses him, with Haaland sitting at 23 goals.
Mbappé is close behind with 23 goals in total and 18 from open play, ranking sixth and seventh, respectively, among players in Europe’s top five leagues. Both forwards are enjoying highly productive seasons.
There are concerns that, despite scoring 31.2% of City’s goals single-handedly, Haaland might actually be limiting the team’s overall play. In a side that dominates possession and leads the Premier League in both touches and passes, Haaland ranks second-lowest for touches per 90 minutes (22.7) among players with over 1,000 minutes played, ahead only of Jamie Vardy (20.0).
Since joining from Borussia Dortmund in the summer of 2022, Haaland has delivered record-breaking, treble-winning goal tallies in his first season and has continued to score at an elite rate. However, concerns persist that his minimal involvement outside of scoring is contributing to City’s struggles this season.
Without a striker actively participating in their build-up play, City often find themselves operating with a numerical disadvantage. In last week’s defeat to Arsenal, Haaland was largely absent, registering just 10 touches in 90 minutes. He has yet to record more than 33 touches in any game this season across all competitions. While this wasn’t an issue in his first two seasons, City could certainly benefit from more involvement from their number nine at this stage.
Mbappé’s Adaptation at Madrid: A Work in Progress
Mbappé arrived at a Real Madrid side already riding high as reigning La Liga and European champions. The team had thrived without a traditional centre-forward, with Vinícius Júnior— a Ballon d’Or contender— dominating the left-sided attacking role that Mbappé naturally prefers.
Fitting into a star-studded lineup that also included Jude Bellingham and Rodrygo was never going to be seamless, especially after the retirement of midfield legend Toni Kroos. As a result, Mbappé’s early struggles led to doubts about whether he could truly coexist with Vinícius in Madrid’s system.
Yet, signing Mbappé was an inevitability. One of the world’s most electrifying forwards was available on a free transfer and eager to join. A club built for Galácticos was never going to miss out on such an opportunity.
Predictably, accommodating Mbappé, Vinícius, Bellingham, and Rodrygo in the same lineup has had its challenges. The midfield has lacked control without Kroos, and defensive stability has suffered— Madrid have already conceded two or more goals in 12 games this season, including heavy defeats to Barcelona (4-0 and 5-2).
Their performances in big matches have been particularly underwhelming, and Mbappé has yet to make a significant impact on these occasions. In 10 games against teams ranked in the top 30 of Opta’s Power Rankings, Madrid have secured just two wins— both against Atalanta— while Mbappé has managed only three goals.
The only one of those three goals that directly influenced the outcome was his equaliser in the recent Madrid derby against Atlético. While his overall contribution in high-stakes games has been questioned, that goal could signal a turning point.
Encouragingly, Mbappé’s recent form has been much stronger. He and Vinícius are proving they can thrive together, with the Frenchman netting nine goals in his last eight appearances across all competitions.
Although early-season doubts about Mbappé are fading, Madrid’s uninspired 1-0 defeat to Espanyol last week suggests there’s still room for improvement. A statement performance against Manchester City would go a long way in silencing any lingering skepticism.
City’s Struggles Persist Amid Haaland’s Mixed Form
Manchester City’s unconvincing run of form shows no signs of improvement. Last weekend, they suffered a heavy defeat against Arsenal, just days after narrowly securing a Champions League play-off spot. Their progression was far from dominant—they had to come from behind to beat Club Brugge on the final matchday and only advanced thanks to wins in their three most straightforward fixtures against Brugge, Slovan Bratislava, and Sparta Prague.
Despite City’s struggles, Haaland’s goal output remains strong, with seven in his last eight games. However, there’s a lingering sense that he isn’t quite at his peak. At his best, Haaland is a relentless attacking force, yet he hasn’t been getting as many opportunities in recent weeks. Earlier in the season, he registered five or more shots in 13 of his first 17 league and Champions League games. In contrast, across his last 15 appearances, he has hit that mark just once—in a victory over relegation-threatened Leicester.
That said, Haaland has still maintained an impressive scoring rate despite not being at his absolute best. His workload has been relentless, with little respite—he has started 33 games this season and has been substituted off just five times, only twice before the 81st minute.
Encouragingly, his finishing has shown signs of improvement. After enduring his worst spell of underperformance in front of goal since joining City, Haaland has recently begun outscoring his expected goals. His underlying numbers indicate a potential return to peak form—making it a risky bet to doubt him turning things around.
Facing a severely weakened Madrid defense missing all four of its first-choice defenders, Haaland won’t be too concerned about limited touches on the ball. He’ll back himself to find the net even with few opportunities. While he has drawn blanks against Liverpool, Newcastle, Aston Villa, Inter, and Juventus this season, he has delivered in key moments—scoring both home and away against Arsenal and Chelsea, as well as finding the net against PSG recently. His presence remains a constant threat in big matches.
Haaland vs Mbappé: The Defining Duel of a Generation
With 47 goals in 47 Champions League appearances, Haaland is rapidly closing in on the competition’s all-time top 10 scorers, currently just four behind Mbappé, who sits in eighth. Both strikers have the potential to one day challenge Cristiano Ronaldo’s record of 140 goals, cementing their legacy as the defining forwards of the next decade.
In the short term, however, their focus is on shaping their respective clubs’ seasons. For Manchester City, the Champions League is their last chance to salvage the 2024-25 campaign. Meanwhile, although Madrid are determined to secure back-to-back La Liga titles for the first time since 2008, European glory remains their ultimate goal. As the reigning champions and record holders with 15 titles, this is the competition that defines them—one that Mbappé joined Madrid specifically to win. Anything less than lifting the trophy would be seen as a failure.
City vs. Madrid has become a staple of European football, and this season marks just the fourth time in history that two clubs have met in the Champions League for four consecutive seasons. However, this year’s clash carries an added layer of intrigue—two of football’s biggest superstars, Haaland and Mbappé, could determine the outcome. Their performances on this stage may shape how they are judged in years to come, and there’s no better time to make a statement than now.
Read More: UEFA Champions League 2024/25: Man City vs Real Madrid – Preview and Prediction
FAQs
How has Kylian Mbappé adapted to Real Madrid’s playing style?
Mbappé initially struggled to fit into a Madrid team that already had Vinícius Júnior, Jude Bellingham, and Rodrygo in attack. However, his recent performances, including nine goals in his last eight games, show he is settling in well.
Is Erling Haaland’s lack of involvement affecting Manchester City’s performances?
Despite scoring 31.2% of City’s goals, Haaland has had minimal involvement in their build-up play. His low number of touches per game has raised concerns, but he remains a constant goal threat in big matches.
How do Mbappé and Haaland compare in the UEFA Champions League?
Haaland has 47 goals in 47 Champions League games, while Mbappé is slightly ahead in the all-time top 10 scorers list. Both are seen as future contenders to challenge Cristiano Ronaldo’s record of 140 goals.
Can Manchester City’s form impact their Champions League hopes?
City’s inconsistent form, including struggles in the league and Champions League play-offs, has raised doubts. However, Haaland’s goalscoring remains strong, and his recent performances suggest he is regaining top form.
Why is Manchester City vs. Real Madrid a must-watch fixture?
This is the fourth consecutive season City and Madrid have met in the Champions League, making it one of Europe’s biggest rivalries. With Haaland and Mbappé leading their teams, this clash could define the next era of football.
