Elizabeth Olsen Stars in A24’s Supernatural Romance ‘Eternity’ – First Trailer Reveals Otherworldly Love Dilemma

Hollywood’s beloved Marvel star Elizabeth Olsen is stepping into uncharted territory with A24‘s upcoming supernatural romantic comedy “Eternity.” The newly released trailer showcases Olsen in perhaps her most emotionally complex role yet, where love transcends death itself and eternal decisions must be made in just seven days.

Elizabeth Olsen Takes Center Stage in A24’s Most Ambitious Romance

In the A24 film Eternity, Joan (Elizabeth Olsen) is a woman of her word. When she married her husband Larry (Miles Teller), the phrase “till death do us part” meant something to her. It meant something to her first husband Luke (Callum Turner), too, but his life being claimed while he was away at war assured it was a short-lived agreement. What makes this premise particularly compelling is how Elizabeth Olsen navigates the impossible moral and emotional complexity of choosing between two loves that were never meant to compete.

The Eternity trailer reveals a stunning premise that feels both fantastical and deeply human. Larry arrives at the junction, essentially a train platform where souls can decide where they want to spend the rest of eternity. They have one week to make their decision. Larry is thrilled when he reunites with Joan, knowing they can make the choice together. But Luke has been waiting decades to do the same.

Elizabeth Olsen’s portrayal of Joan appears to be her most vulnerable and emotionally demanding role since “WandaVision.” The actress must convey the overwhelming confusion of reconnecting with two deceased husbands while grappling with an eternal commitment that will define her afterlife experience.

The Eternity Trailer Showcases Stellar Performances and Visual Storytelling

“I never dreamt you this clearly,” Joan tells Luke, who says she’s exactly how he’s dreamt her during all of their years apart. This poignant exchange demonstrates how the Eternity trailer masterfully balances romantic longing with supernatural elements. The visual presentation appears to channel classic Hollywood romance while maintaining A24’s signature artistic sensibility.

Director David Freyne has crafted what appears to be a sophisticated exploration of love, loss, and second chances. “I’ve just been reunited with both of my dead husbands and I have to pick where to spend eternity,” Joan says, overwhelmed and torn. This central conflict drives the narrative tension while allowing Elizabeth Olsen to showcase her remarkable emotional range.

From there, the afterlife romance olympics begin. Luke has all of the slick one-liners and the advantage of 67 years of practice. Larry, on the other hand, has high hopes and his fingers crossed. The competitive dynamic between Miles Teller and Callum Turner promises to deliver both comedic moments and genuine romantic tension.

Star-Studded Cast and Creative Team Behind Eternity

Elizabeth Olsen leads an impressive ensemble cast that includes Da’Vine Joy Randolph, Olga Merediz, and John Early. The film represents a significant collaboration between A24 and accomplished filmmakers, with David Freyne directing and Pat Cunnane contributing to the screenplay.

The production benefits from the expertise of Oscar-nominated producers Trevor White and Tim White under their Star Thrower Entertainment banner, which is best known for producing The Post and King Richard. This level of production talent suggests that Eternity will deliver both artistic merit and commercial appeal.

Miles Teller and Callum Turner bring distinct personalities to their respective roles as Joan’s competing loves. Joan is played by WandaVision’s Elizabeth Olsen. Her two potential soul-mates are Callum Turner and Miles Teller, with a supporting cast that includes Da’Vine Joy Randolph, Betty Buckley, John Early, and Jeff Sanca.

Cast and Crew Information Table

Elizabeth Olsen’s Perspective on the Film

Elizabeth Olsen has expressed genuine enthusiasm for the project, describing it as both entertaining and artistically satisfying. “It’s real fun,” Olsen told Extra about the film earlier this year. “It’s a callback to Billy Wilder films. I think it’s gonna be a special romantic comedy that we’re all really proud of. I’m excited for it to come out this year.”

Her comparison to Billy Wilder films suggests that Eternity will blend sophisticated humor with emotional depth, characteristics that defined classic Hollywood cinema. This approach aligns perfectly with A24’s reputation for elevating genre material through thoughtful storytelling and exceptional performances.

The Unique Afterlife Setting and Thematic Elements

In an afterlife where souls have one week to decide where to spend eternity, Joan is faced with the impossible choice between the man she spent her life with and her first love, who died young and has waited decades for her to arrive. This premise allows the film to explore themes of destiny, true love, and the nature of eternal commitment.

The seven-day limitation creates natural dramatic tension while forcing characters to confront their deepest feelings under extraordinary pressure. “A lot has happened in a week! You died! I died! I’ve just been reunited with both of my dead husbands. And I have to pick where to spend eternity?!” This line from the Eternity trailer perfectly captures the absurd yet emotionally genuine situation that Elizabeth Olsen’s character faces.

Production Timeline and Release Information

Eternity is scheduled for theatrical release in November. The film will make its world premiere at the Toronto International Film Festival, indicating strong industry confidence in its quality and commercial potential. David Freyne directs the romantic comedy which will debut at TIFF 2025.

It was filmed last year, with Da’Vine Joy Randolph, John Early and Olga Merediz added to the cast. The production timeline suggests careful attention to post-production elements, potentially including sophisticated visual effects to create the otherworldly afterlife setting.

Film Production Timeline

Musical Elements and Visual Style

The trailer for A24’s ‘Eternity,’ starring Elizabeth Olsen, Miles Teller, and Callum Turner, has been released and is set to Yeah Yeah Yeahs’ “Different Today.” This musical choice indicates that the film will blend contemporary sensibilities with its timeless romantic themes.

The Eternity trailer suggests a visual approach that balances fantastical elements with intimate character moments. A24’s involvement typically ensures high production values and distinctive cinematography that serves the story’s emotional core rather than overwhelming it with spectacle.

Critical Reception and Industry Anticipation

Elizabeth Olsen is one of the best actors when it comes to balancing grief, hope, joy, and loss. It looks like we’re in for even more devastation because her new movie Eternity has her making an impossible choice: picking between Callum Turner and Miles Teller.

Industry observers have noted the film’s potential to showcase Elizabeth Olsen’s dramatic capabilities while delivering accessible entertainment. The combination of A24’s artistic credibility, Elizabeth Olsen’s proven talent, and the unique supernatural premise positions Eternity as a significant addition to 2025’s film landscape.

Comparison to Classic Cinema and Contemporary Romance

Elizabeth Olsen is getting her own take on “Defending Your Life” with a love triangle twist. This comparison to Albert Brooks’ beloved 1991 comedy suggests that Eternity will explore similar themes of self-examination and personal growth within an afterlife setting.

The film appears to modernize classic romantic comedy tropes while incorporating supernatural elements that allow for deeper exploration of love, commitment, and personal identity. Elizabeth Olsen’s involvement ensures that the emotional stakes will feel authentic despite the fantastical circumstances.

Read More: Monica Barbaro Seals the Deal: Oscar Nominee Confirmed for Luca Guadagnino’s ‘Artificial’

FAQs