Alexander Isak at Liverpool: Why the £125M Star Is Struggling to Find His Form

The summer of 2025 promised to be transformative for Liverpool Football Club. After securing their status as Premier League champions, the Reds made a statement of intent by breaking the British transfer record to sign Alexander Isak from Newcastle United for a staggering £125 million. The Swedish striker, who had terrorized Premier League defenses during his time at St. James’ Park, was supposed to be the final piece in Liverpool’s puzzle for European dominance. However, more than two months into his Anfield career, the 26-year-old finds himself at the center of growing scrutiny as his new club struggles through their worst start to a season in recent memory.

The Numbers Don’t Lie: A Concerning Statistical Picture

Alexander Isak’s Liverpool career has been defined by underwhelming statistics that paint a stark picture of a player yet to find his rhythm. In 382 minutes of football across all competitions, the Swedish international has managed just 105 touches of the ball, registered 11 shots with only five finding the target, and scored a solitary goal against Championship side Southampton in the Carabao Cup.

These figures represent a dramatic departure from the prolific form that convinced Liverpool to invest such a significant sum. During his final season at Newcastle, Isak scored 27 goals in 36 appearances, demonstrating the clinical finishing ability that made him one of Europe’s most coveted strikers. The contrast between those numbers and his current output highlights the magnitude of his adaptation challenges.

The timing of these struggles couldn’t be worse for Liverpool, who find themselves already four points behind league leaders Arsenal after just eight Premier League matches. Sunday’s devastating 2-1 home defeat to arch-rivals Manchester United marked the club’s fourth consecutive loss across all competitions, a run that has placed immense pressure on both player and club to find solutions quickly.

The Self-Inflicted Wound: Pre-Season Disruption

Perhaps the most significant factor in Alexander Isak’s slow start at Liverpool stems from his controversial decision to effectively go on strike at Newcastle to force through his transfer. This calculated gamble, while ultimately successful in securing his dream move, came at a considerable cost to his preparation for the new season.

Isak’s absence from Newcastle’s entire pre-season program represents more than just missed training sessions. The Swedish striker missed the club’s three-game tour to Singapore and South Korea, skipped all four friendlies in the UK, and remained absent for the opening three Premier League fixtures of the campaign. This self-imposed exile meant that when he finally arrived at Anfield on deadline day, he was significantly behind his new teammates in terms of match fitness and tactical familiarity.

The ripple effects of this decision have been profound. Individual training sessions at Real Sociedad in Spain and later on Tyneside proved to be no substitute for the collective preparation that defines modern football. Match sharpness, understanding of teammates’ movements, and the instinctive reactions that separate elite strikers from the merely good all require consistent practice with the same group of players.

Liverpool’s coaching staff, led by Arne Slot, acknowledged this challenge from the outset. They implemented a gradual integration program, slowly building up Isak’s workload before his debut against Atletico Madrid on September 17, a full 16 days after his arrival. However, the necessity of playing his way to match fitness during competitive fixtures rather than pre-season friendlies placed additional pressure on both player and team during crucial early-season matches.

Tactical Adaptation: Finding His Place in Slot’s System

The transition from Eddie Howe’s Newcastle to Arne Slot’s Liverpool represents more than just a change of scenery for Alexander Isak. The tactical demands and positional responsibilities in each system differ significantly, requiring the striker to essentially relearn aspects of his game that had become second nature on Tyneside.

At Newcastle, Isak operated in a system that maximized his strengths through direct service and clear positional structure. The relationship he had developed with teammates like Jacob Murphy, who provided seven Premier League assists last season, was built on understanding and repetition. Murphy’s consistent crosses and through balls played to Isak’s movement patterns, creating the most prolific partnership in the division.

Liverpool’s system under Slot demands greater versatility from the central striker. Rather than simply occupying the penalty area and waiting for service, Isak is expected to drop deep to link play, drift wide to create space for others, and maintain high-intensity pressing when out of possession. These tactical adjustments require time to master, particularly when integrating with new teammates who are also learning the system.

The evidence of this tactical transition is visible in Isak’s positioning throughout matches. Against Manchester United, heat maps showed him frequently receiving the ball in deeper areas with his back to goal, a significant departure from his Newcastle role where he operated primarily in the final third. While this demonstrates his willingness to adapt, it also explains why his goal threat has diminished as he spends more time facilitating play rather than finishing moves.

The Clinical Edge: Where Has the Finishing Gone?

Perhaps the most concerning aspect of Alexander Isak’s early Liverpool struggles has been his apparent loss of clinical finishing, the attribute that most defined his success at Newcastle. Several missed opportunities have highlighted this decline, none more glaring than his one-on-one chance against Manchester United that should have been routine for a player of his caliber.

When Ibrahima Konate released Isak in behind the United defense with a perfectly weighted through ball, it appeared to be the moment that would ignite his Liverpool career. The striker’s run was expertly timed, beating the offside trap with ease, but when faced with goalkeeper Senne Lammens, his shot was struck too close to the keeper, who saved comfortably with his legs. For a player who built his reputation on converting exactly these types of chances, the miss represented more than just a moment of poor execution.

This pattern has been repeated across multiple matches and competitions. Against Crystal Palace, a slick one-two with Alexis Mac Allister created space in the penalty area, but Isak’s subsequent effort flashed wide of the post after some neat footwork had eliminated the defender. While not a simple opportunity, it was exactly the type of chance that peak-form Isak would typically curl into the far corner with confidence.

His aerial game, traditionally a strength, has also suffered. Two particularly notable misses came from crosses that found him unmarked in the penalty area. Against Palace, Curtis Jones delivered an inviting cross that Isak met cleanly but directed over the crossbar. A week later at Chelsea, Mohamed Salah’s delivery again found the Swedish striker unmarked, but once more the header sailed harmlessly over the goal.

The psychological impact of these misses cannot be understated. For a striker whose confidence is closely tied to his goal-scoring record, each squandered opportunity adds pressure to the next chance. The fear of missing can become self-fulfilling, creating a negative cycle that even the most talented players struggle to break.

Service and Support: The Collective Challenge

While Alexander Isak’s individual struggles with finishing and adaptation are significant, they exist within the broader context of Liverpool’s collective challenges. The service provided to the striker has been inconsistent, lacking the quality and frequency that defined his most productive periods at Newcastle.

The contrast is stark when comparing Isak’s current situation to his previous environment. Jacob Murphy’s seven assists to Isak last season represented more than just individual brilliance; they demonstrated a partnership built on mutual understanding and consistent positioning. Murphy knew exactly when and where to deliver the ball, while Isak’s movement patterns were perfectly synchronized with his teammate’s crossing tendencies.

At Liverpool, no such relationship has yet emerged. The team’s attacking structure has been in constant flux, with heavy rotation affecting the consistency of service. Mohamed Salah and Cody Gakpo, primarily goalscoring wingers rather than natural creators, have struggled to provide the type of service that maximizes Isak’s strengths. While Salah’s assist numbers have improved recently, his natural inclination remains to shoot rather than create for others.

The tactical approach under Arne Slot has also contributed to service issues. Liverpool’s tendency to concede early goals in recent matches has forced them into reactive mode, with opponents content to defend deep and deny space in behind. This defensive structure limits the opportunities for the through balls and crosses that Isak thrives on, instead forcing him to operate in congested areas with his back to goal.

The relationship with fellow newcomer Florian Wirtz offers some hope for future improvement. The German playmaker, who arrived from Bayer Leverkusen for an initial £100 million, has shown flashes of understanding with Isak during their limited time together. In their combined appearances, Wirtz has created several opportunities for the striker, including two clear chances in the box against Atletico Madrid that Isak was unable to convert.

However, these partnerships require time and consistency to develop fully. The frequent rotation and tactical adjustments have prevented any stable understanding from forming, leaving Isak somewhat isolated in his search for goals and confidence.

The Psychological Factor: Managing Expectations and Pressure

The psychological dimension of Alexander Isak’s struggles cannot be overlooked when analyzing his difficult start at Liverpool. The £125 million price tag brings with it an enormous weight of expectation, not just from supporters and media, but from teammates and coaching staff who expect immediate impact from such a significant investment.

Historical context suggests that Isak is not naturally immune to pressure situations. His former Newcastle teammates often described him as a complex character who required specific management to reach his potential. The consensus was that he needed provocation or motivation to spark into his best form, a characteristic that both helped and hindered his development.

The most telling example of this came during his difficult start to the 2023-24 season at Newcastle. After scoring just once in six games and delivering a particularly poor performance in a 3-1 defeat at Fulham, Eddie Howe felt compelled to intervene. The Newcastle manager delivered some home truths about expectations and provided a detailed tactical presentation about movement patterns and positioning.

This intervention proved transformative, with Isak responding by scoring 27 goals in his remaining 36 appearances. The dramatic improvement demonstrated both his quality and his responsiveness to proper guidance, but also highlighted his need for specific management approaches.

At Liverpool, Arne Slot has taken a more patient approach, publicly emphasizing that Isak was signed for six years, not six weeks. This long-term perspective is designed to reduce pressure, but it also requires the striker to self-motivate during a difficult period. The support of captain Virgil van Dijk, who admired Isak even when they were opponents, has been valuable, but it cannot replace the confidence that comes from consistent goal-scoring.

The international break has provided no respite from this pressure. Isak’s struggles have extended to his Sweden appearances, where he failed to score in defeats to both Switzerland and Kosovo. These results have left Sweden facing a battle to qualify for the next World Cup, adding another layer of pressure to a player already struggling for form and confidence.

Team Dynamics: Integration Challenges

Beyond individual adaptation, Alexander Isak faces the complex challenge of integrating into an established Liverpool dressing room filled with strong personalities and competing ambitions. The striker has entered an environment where several players are simultaneously trying to justify their own significant investments, maintain their status, or prove their continued value to the team.

Florian Wirtz and Hugo Ekitike, fellow expensive signings, are working to validate their own substantial price tags. Mohamed Salah, despite his advancing years, remains determined to prove he is still the team’s primary attacking threat, retaining penalty duties despite Isak’s arrival. Cody Gakpo and Federico Chiesa are fighting for attacking positions after contributing to last season’s title success, while Luis Diaz and Diogo Jota are eager to reclaim their places in the starting eleven.

This internal competition, while potentially beneficial for squad depth, creates a complex dynamic that requires careful management. Each player’s desire to impress can sometimes come at the expense of collective cohesion, particularly when newcomers like Isak are still learning the patterns of play that make teammates most effective.

The structural changes throughout Liverpool’s team have compounded these integration challenges. Two new full-backs and heavy rotation in the number 10 position have created constant flux in the team’s shape and relationships. For a striker who relies heavily on understanding his teammates’ movements and preferences, this constant change makes adaptation significantly more difficult.

Slot’s attempts to create stability by selecting the same starting eleven for consecutive Premier League matches have been undermined by early goals conceded, forcing tactical changes and rotations that disrupt the rhythm he’s trying to establish. The resulting sense of flux affects every player but is particularly challenging for a newcomer still learning his role within the system.

The Broader Context: Liverpool’s Systemic Issues

Alexander Isak’s individual struggles cannot be separated from Liverpool’s broader systemic problems that have contributed to their disappointing start to the season. The team’s defensive vulnerabilities, having conceded the first goal in each of their last three Premier League matches, have forced them into reactive patterns that don’t suit their attacking players’ strengths.

When teams take early leads against Liverpool, they can afford to sit deep and maintain defensive shape without taking risks. This approach creates the low blocks that Isak has struggled against throughout his career, limiting space for the runs in behind that represent his greatest threat. Instead of operating as a poacher in the penalty area, he’s forced to drop deep and link play, moving him away from goal-scoring positions.

The team’s inability to control games as effectively as they did during their title-winning campaign has broader implications for all attacking players. Midfield dominance allows strikers to remain higher up the pitch, knowing that possession will eventually find them in dangerous areas. Without this control, strikers must contribute more to build-up play, reducing their goal threat.

Liverpool’s structural flaws have been particularly evident in big matches, where the team has struggled to impose their style of play. The defeat to Manchester United showcased many of these issues, with Isak receiving minimal service apart from Konate’s exceptional through ball. The lack of creative spark from midfield and wide areas has left the striker isolated and ineffective.

These systemic issues extend beyond individual matches to affect team preparation and confidence. When the collective unit isn’t functioning optimally, individual players inevitably suffer. For a newcomer like Isak, who hasn’t yet built the relationships and understanding that might help him thrive despite team struggles, these broader problems become magnified.

Comparative Analysis: Historical Precedent

Alexander Isak’s difficult start at Liverpool can be better understood through comparison with other high-profile striker signings who faced similar challenges. The history of football is littered with talented forwards who required extended adaptation periods before reaching their potential at new clubs.

Fernando Torres’s move from Liverpool to Chelsea in 2011 provides an interesting parallel, albeit in reverse. The Spanish striker, who had been prolific at Anfield, struggled dramatically at Stamford Bridge despite his £50 million price tag. His goal return dropped significantly as he failed to adapt to a different system and lost confidence in front of goal. While the circumstances differ, the pattern of a proven striker struggling in a new environment demonstrates how complex these transitions can be.

More recently, Romelu Lukaku’s various moves have shown how even experienced strikers can struggle when systems don’t suit their strengths. His return to Chelsea from Inter Milan was marked by tactical disagreements and poor integration, despite his undoubted quality. These examples suggest that success isn’t guaranteed simply because a player has proven ability.

Conversely, successful adaptations like Harry Kane’s seamless transition to Bayern Munich or Erling Haaland’s immediate impact at Manchester City show what’s possible when circumstances align. Both players joined teams whose systems maximized their strengths and received consistent service from the outset.

The key difference often lies in preparation time, system suitability, and the presence of complementary players. Isak’s situation at Liverpool currently lacks some of these elements, but history suggests that quality players eventually find their level given time and proper support.

Tactical Solutions: Potential Pathways Forward

Addressing Alexander Isak’s struggles requires both individual development and systemic changes within Liverpool’s approach. Several tactical adjustments could help unlock his potential while the broader team relationships develop naturally over time.

Formation flexibility represents one immediate solution. Slot’s commitment to a 4-3-3 system may not optimize Isak’s strengths in the current circumstances. A temporary shift to a 4-2-3-1 or 3-5-2 formation could provide the striker with more natural support and clearer positional responsibilities. These systems would allow for a dedicated number 10 to supply him consistently while reducing his defensive obligations.

Player positioning adjustments could also yield immediate benefits. Rather than asking Isak to drop deep regularly, Liverpool could instruct him to maintain higher positions while other players take responsibility for link-up play. This would place him closer to goal-scoring positions and reduce the energy spent on build-up contributions.

The development of set-piece routines specifically designed for Isak’s aerial ability represents an underutilized opportunity. His movement in the penalty area suggests this could be a valuable source of goals while his confidence rebuilds through other aspects of his game.

Perhaps most importantly, establishing consistent partnerships through reduced rotation could accelerate the understanding that leads to better service. Identifying which combination of players provides the best service to Isak and persisting with that group, even through temporary poor results, may yield better long-term outcomes.

The Road to Recovery: Lessons from Newcastle

The most encouraging precedent for Alexander Isak’s eventual success at Liverpool comes from his own history at Newcastle, particularly his recovery from early-season struggles during the 2023-24 campaign. The transformation that followed Eddie Howe’s intervention offers a blueprint for potential improvement at Anfield.

The key elements of that Newcastle turnaround were clear communication of expectations, detailed tactical instruction, and consistent faith in the player’s ability. Howe’s willingness to address issues directly while maintaining support created the environment for Isak to rediscover his form spectacularly.

Arne Slot’s approach has been more patient to this point, emphasizing long-term development over immediate intervention. However, the Newcastle example suggests that sometimes direct communication and tactical clarity can accelerate improvement. The Swedish striker has shown throughout his career that he responds well to clear expectations and detailed guidance.

The relationships Isak built with Newcastle teammates didn’t develop overnight, but once established, they became the foundation for his most productive period. The partnerships with Murphy, Bruno Guimaraes, and others took months to reach full effectiveness, suggesting that Liverpool fans may need to extend similar patience for new relationships to flourish.

Most importantly, the Newcastle experience demonstrates that Isak possesses the quality and mentality to overcome difficult periods. His 27 goals in 36 games following that early-season intervention represent the level he can reach when circumstances align properly.

Mental Resilience and Character

Throughout this difficult period, Alexander Isak has shown no outward signs of panic or distress, maintaining the laid-back demeanor that characterized his Newcastle years. This psychological resilience, while sometimes mistaken for lack of urgency, has historically served him well during challenging periods.

His decision to force the Liverpool move, despite the risks to his legacy at Newcastle, demonstrated the ambition and determination that drive elite athletes. This same mentality suggests he possesses the character necessary to overcome current difficulties and establish himself as a key figure at Anfield.

The support structure around Isak at Liverpool appears solid, with Virgil van Dijk taking a particular interest in his development and integration. The Dutch captain’s experience with high-pressure situations and major transfers provides valuable guidance for a player navigating similar challenges.

However, the ultimate responsibility for improvement lies with Isak himself. His track record suggests he has the tools necessary for success, but unlocking them in his new environment requires continued patience, application, and perhaps some tactical adjustments from his coaching staff.

Read More: Maccabi Tel Aviv Refuse Away Tickets for Aston Villa Europa League Clash

Frequently Asked Questions