The Marvel star and Barbie actor has ignited a crucial conversation about systemic barriers facing Asian talent in the entertainment industry. In a recent social media post, the actor criticized what he described as a disturbing reversal in visibility for Asian performers, challenging Hollywood’s continued reluctance to invest in Asian-led projects despite their proven track record of commercial and critical success.
Table of Contents
The Numbers Tell a Troubling Story
Recent data from USC’s Annenberg Inclusion Initiative reveals the magnitude of the problem Simu Liu is highlighting. Asian speaking characters decreased from 18.4 percent in 2023 to 13.5 percent in 2024, marking a significant reversal of progress made over the previous decade. Meanwhile, white characters increased to 63.6 percent in 2024 from 55.7 percent in 2023.
| Year | Asian Characters | White Characters | Change |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2023 | 18.4% | 55.7% | Baseline |
| 2024 | 13.5% | 63.6% | -4.9% Asian / +7.9% White |
| 2007 | 3.4% | 78% | Historical comparison |
This regression contradicts the narrative that Hollywood has made steady progress toward inclusive casting. The data suggests that gains achieved through groundbreaking films may be evaporating rather than solidifying into lasting industry change.
Studios Label Asian Actors as Financial Risks
The Canadian-Chinese actor didn’t mince words in his assessment of studio executives’ attitudes. Responding to discussions about limited opportunities for Asian men in romantic lead roles, he wrote that studios persist in viewing Asian talent as risky investments despite overwhelming evidence to the contrary.
Liu countered studio concerns by citing several Asian-led films including “Crazy Rich Asians,” “Farewell,” “Minari,” “Past Lives” and “Everything Everywhere All at Once,” noting that every single one achieved financial success. The actor’s own Marvel debut, Shang-Chi and the Legend of the Ten Rings, grossed more than $432 million worldwide and broke Labor Day weekend box office records.
Financial Success Hasn’t Translated to Opportunity
The commercial performance of Asian-led projects tells a compelling story that contradicts Hollywood’s risk-averse stance:
| Film | Worldwide Box Office | Budget | Critical Reception |
|---|---|---|---|
| Crazy Rich Asians (2018) | $239 million | $30 million | 91% RT |
| Everything Everywhere All at Once (2022) | $143 million | $25 million | 7 Oscars |
| Shang-Chi (2021) | $432 million | $150 million | 91% RT |
| Minari (2020) | $15.5 million | $2 million | Oscar nominated |
Yet the first Asian-led Marvel superhero film still awaits a sequel announcement four years after its release, while other franchises with weaker box office returns continue to move forward with follow-up projects. This disparity illuminates the double standard Liu describes in his critique of industry decision-making.
The Double Standard in Hollywood’s Risk Assessment
The actor pointed out that no Asian actor has lost a studio close to 100 million dollars, while white actors who have lost studios 200 million dollars twice continue landing major roles. This observation cuts to the heart of systemic bias in greenlighting decisions.
Fellow Asian actors face similar barriers. Manny Jacinto recently revealed he’s primarily receiving dad role auditions despite his range as a performer, while established stars like Daniel Dae Kim and John Cho have long spoken about the scarcity of romantic lead opportunities available to Asian men.
Beyond Box Office: The Cultural Impact Gap
The conversation extends beyond theatrical releases. Social media users responded by noting that audiences increasingly turn to Asian-produced content, with K-dramas and Korean pop culture contributing billions to regional economies. The success of Korean entertainment demonstrates substantial global appetite for Asian stories and performers that Hollywood appears reluctant to acknowledge.
Author Kat Lieu connected the issue to her own experience in publishing, where despite authoring the first Asian cookie cookbook and being a TEDx speaker, national media outlets consistently overlook her work in favor of white male authors. This parallel suggests the problem transcends film and reflects broader patterns in cultural industries.
Historical Context: From Erasure to Regression
Understanding the current backslide requires examining the baseline from which Asian representation grew. A comprehensive study of 1,300 top-grossing films from 2007 to 2019 found that 39% failed to depict even one Asian or Pacific Islander character. Even more striking, only 44 films or 3.4% featured an Asian or Pacific Islander lead or co-lead across those 13 years.
The breakthrough era of Crazy Rich Asians seemed to promise systemic change, but recent statistics reveal those hopes were premature. Rather than building on momentum, the industry appears to be retreating to familiar patterns of exclusion.
The Fight Against a Prejudiced System
Liu characterized the situation as fighting against a deeply prejudiced system, adding that most days it’s difficult. His candid acknowledgment of the emotional toll speaks to frustration felt by Asian talent who continue producing excellent work only to face persistent gatekeeping.
The actor has consistently used his platform to advocate for representation since his breakthrough role. His willingness to publicly challenge industry practices reflects growing impatience among Asian creatives who see their proven track records dismissed while less successful projects receive continued investment based on the race of their stars.
What the Data Reveals About Systemic Barriers
Though Asian characters increased from 3.4% of speaking roles in 2007 to 13.5% in 2024, the decline from 2023 to 2024 signals that progress is beginning to reverse. This regression occurs despite no corresponding change in the Asian American population, which continues growing as a percentage of the United States demographic makeup.
Behind the camera, disparities persist as well. Across 1,447 directors evaluated in the study period, only 3.5% were Asian or Pacific Islander, with just three of these positions held by women. The data demonstrates that representation gaps exist throughout the creative pipeline, not solely in casting decisions.
Industry Response and Public Reaction
The actor’s comments sparked widespread discussion across social media platforms, with many expressing disappointment that groundbreaking successes haven’t translated into sustained opportunity. Fans and industry observers noted the frustration that films like Everything Everywhere All at Once continue being treated as surprise hits rather than expected outcomes of quality filmmaking with talented performers.
Some pointed to the delayed or abandoned sequels for Asian-led properties while franchises with comparable or inferior box office performance move forward with multiple installments. This pattern suggests that commercial success alone doesn’t overcome the industry’s ingrained biases about which stories and stars merit continued investment.
Demanding Accountability
The Shang-Chi star’s intervention represents more than venting frustration. By quantifying the regression and explicitly naming the prejudice underlying casting decisions, he challenges studios to reconcile their stated commitment to diversity with their actual greenlight patterns.
Whether this latest call to action produces meaningful change remains uncertain. Previous moments that seemed poised to transform industry practices have yielded temporary gains followed by retrenchment. Breaking this cycle will require sustained pressure from creators, audiences, and stakeholders who recognize that authentic representation benefits both storytelling quality and commercial viability.
The conversation Liu has reignited matters because it exposes the gap between Hollywood’s rhetoric about inclusion and the reality facing talented performers who continue proving their value while being denied commensurate opportunities. Until that disconnect resolves, the fight he describes will continue.
FAQs
What did Simu Liu say about Asian representation in Hollywood?
The actor condemned the decline in Asian visibility onscreen, calling it appalling and accusing studios of viewing Asian talent as risky despite consistent commercial success of Asian-led films.
How much has Asian representation declined according to recent data?
USC Annenberg research shows Asian speaking characters dropped from 18.4% in 2023 to 13.5% in 2024, while white character representation increased during the same period.
Which Asian-led films has Simu Liu cited as financial successes?
He referenced Crazy Rich Asians, Minari, The Farewell, Past Lives, Everything Everywhere All at Once, and his own film Shang-Chi and the Legend of the Ten Rings as examples of commercially successful Asian-led projects.
Will there be a Shang-Chi sequel?
Despite the first film’s box office success four years ago, no sequel has been officially announced, though the character will appear in the upcoming Avengers: Doomsday.
What is the broader impact of limited Asian representation?
Beyond film, the pattern affects multiple creative industries and contributes to audiences increasingly seeking Asian-produced content from Korean and other regional entertainment markets that better reflect diverse stories.
